We’ve written a lot on this blog about the tragic result of San Francisco bus accidents.
In the past, fatal Muni bus accidents have cost the city millions in lawsuit settlements, and most importantly, have claimed the lives of far too many San Francisco residents. Over the weekend, new city dweller Emily Dunn was struck and killed by a Muni bus in the city’s Castro District. The police report indicated that Dunn was struck 95% into the crosswalk by a Muni Bus making a left turn, an action that is commonly cited as unsafe.
Earlier this year, Muni agreed to a record settlement of $5.36 million to the family of David Wheeler, a cyclist who was killed in a Muni accident near Ocean Beach. According to documents filed in the San Francisco Superior Court, the Muni operator Roy Timmons failed to stop before turning left and took an unusually tight turning radius. The description of this accident closely mirrors Dunn’s collision over the weekend.
Portland Oregon has also been plagued by an abnormally large number of bus accidents caused by dangerous left turns. Last year, The Oregonian reported that although left-turn accidents were “alarmingly common,” the city refused to adopt a “no-left” policy. And last December, a group of five Portland residents launched a $30 million lawsuit against Portland’s TriMet bus system, after a bus turned left onto a busy street, killing two and injuring three others. Plaintiffs said the accident indicated that TriMet “approved a culture within TriMet that failed to place safe and defensive driving as the top and overriding priority.”
San Francisco should learn from last weekend’s tragic accident and implement measures to reduce dangerous left-turns among all Muni vehicles. If accomplished successfully, reducing left-turns would save the city a bundle in legal costs and more importantly, save lives of promising San Francisco residents.
Photo credit: randychiu
Andy Gillin received his Bachelor’s Degree from the University of California at Berkeley and his law degree from the University of Chicago. He is the managing partner of GJEL Accident Attorneys and has written and lectured in the field of plaintiffs’ personal injury law for numerous organizations. Since 1972 he has been helping seriously injured victims throughout northern California fight & win their personal injury cases. Andy is one of the top awarded & recognized wrongful death lawyers in northern California.